*****************


April 2005

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Blog powered by Typepad

« HEY RUBE! WANNA TRY AT THIS? | Main | Grand Rounds. Period. »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8345304f769e200d83454f76b69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference CSI MEDBLOGS: CODEBLUEBLOG ANALYZES TERRI SCHIAVO'S CT OF THE BRAIN:

» Doctor: The "Water" in Terri’s Brain is a Myth from MediaCulpa
You have probably heard Michael Schiavo’s attorney George Felos say things such as this about Terri Schiavo’s brain: "CT scans just don't lie. When you look at that picture, [Read More]

» "This Brain is Not That Bad" from Oh How I Love Jesus
From CodeBlueBlogs is a very interesting article which shows what is reported to be a 1996 CT scan of Terri Schiavo's brain, and an explanation by a radiologist as to what it all means to him. Please read it. The link is here. I was flabbergasted... [Read More]

» Terri Schiavo: Hidden Agendas? Outright Fraud? from Fat Steve's Blatherings
According to the stories by the "Kill Schiavo Now" crowd, the CAT scan of Terri's brain showed her cerebral cortex has disappeared, rendering her a vegetable. There's now evidence that this is a lie. [Read More]

» Terri's CT Scan, from a physician from Cao's Blog
Sue Bob's Diary has a post referencing a physician, Code Blue Blog, which talks about Terri's CT Scan. The Anchoress draws and interesting conclusions from Code Blue Blog's analysis of the CT Scan: Codeblue blog's Dr. Boyle is concerned. The CT ... [Read More]

» The Politics Of The Terri Schiavo Case from Right Wing News
Across the blogosphere, many people have expressed dismay that Capitol Hill has chosen to get involved in the Terri Schiavo... [Read More]

» The Politics Of The Terri Schiavo Case from Right Wing News
Across the blogosphere, many people have expressed dismay that Capitol Hill has chosen to get involved in the Terri Schiavo... [Read More]

» Is Schiavo's brain gone? from Asymmetrical Information
Most of the anti-Schiavo people (pro-Michael? I don't know what to call them) have been stating unequivocally that Terry Schiavo's cortex has been replaced by spinal fluid. This doctor (the first medico I've seen weigh in on the matter) says that isn't... [Read More]

» Catching my eye: morning A through Z from The Glittering Eye
Here's what's caught my eye this morning: Abu Aardvark has good words about an al Jazeera discussion program that concerned a recent poll on the concerns of the “Arab street”. Courtesy of Across the Bay you might want to take... [Read More]

» Catching my eye: morning A through Z from The Glittering Eye
Here's what's caught my eye this morning: Abu Aardvark has good words about an al Jazeera discussion program that concerned a recent poll on the concerns of the “Arab street”. Courtesy of Across the Bay you might want to take... [Read More]

» Inside Terri's Brain from Mind of Mog
OK, I did find something else interesting. Code Blue Blog has a look inside Terri's brain. He has some faascinating insights. Read the comments too. This one by Dr Tony is telling. I heard an interview on the radio today with a physician who has over... [Read More]

» Catching my eye: morning A through Z from The Glittering Eye
Here's what's caught my eye this morning: Abu Aardvark has good words about an al Jazeera discussion program that concerned a recent poll on the concerns of the “Arab street”. Courtesy of Across the Bay you might want to take... [Read More]

» "Reasonable Doubt" in the Schiavo Case from AmbivaBlog
In criminal law, juries are instructed to find a defendant not guilty as long as his or her guilt cannot be proven "beyond a reasonable doubt." The concept of "reasonable doubt" can be usefully extended by analogy to other situations, [Read More]

» CSI Medblogs: This brain is not that bad from Discarded Lies
CodeBlueBlog: CSI MEDBLOGS: CODEBLUEBLOG ANALYZES TERRI SCHIAVO'S CT OF THE BRAIN. Would you be surprised to discover that the courts have no fucking clue? No? First, I contest the theory that Terri's brain actively continues to degenerate as implied b... [Read More]

» A medical blogger analyzes Terri's CT scan from Bettnet.com - Musings From Domenico Bettinelli
The CodeBlueBlog is written by a healthcare profession with experience reading CT scans and he takes a look at a 1996 scan of Terri Schiavo's brain. He concludes that the [Read More]

» The CT Scan from KelliPundit
One issue though that has been discussed and argued over is the fact that her brain has atrophied and is beyond hope based on a CT Scan. Well that scan and an expert analysis can be found here. [Read More]

» On Partisan Medicine from Janus Online
During the ongoing debate over at The Evangelical Outpost, a commenter provided a quote and link to a physician with apparently first-hand information. But when you get there, you find that CodeBlueBlog is just an example of yet another a... [Read More]

» Terri Schiavo from The Listless Lawyer
Apropos of the post just below this one: We've all heard the claim that Terri Schiavo's brain has been replaced by spinal fluid. Here's a doctor (and medical blogger) that says that isn't correct.... [Read More]

» CT of Terri's Brain from The Black Republican
CodeBlueBlognot filled with spinal fuid, (as some news sources has told us). The doctor provides an explanation of the CT, and the status of the patient shown. A must read for anyone wondering about her true condition. A tip of... [Read More]

» CSI MedBlogs: CodeBlueBlog Analyzes Terri Schiavo's CT Of The Brain from Hyscience
THIS BRAIN IS NOT THAT BAD according to award-winning medical weblog "CodeBlueBlog." [Read More]

» A Radiologist Responds to Terri's CAT Scan from Wittenberg Gate
Have you seen that CT scan of Terri's brain and heard the conclusions that her cerebral cortex is gone and her head filled with cerebral spinal fluid? Have you heard it said that this proves that Terri could not possibly speak, feel or interact with he... [Read More]

» CODEBLUE BLOG ON TERRI'S CT SCAN from MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy
LIQUEFIED BRAIN, MY ASS. CodeBlue Blog analyzes the CT scan of Terri's brain (note: this doctor has analyzed over 10,000 CTs, so it's no amateur opinion) and has a few things to say: First, I contest the theory that Terri's brain actively continues... [Read More]

» CSI MEDBLOGS: CODEBLUEBLOG ANALYZES TERRI SCHIAVO'S CT OF THE BRAIN from bLogicus
How could they gage serial brain degeneration without serial follow-up? And by what mechanism would her brain CONTINUE to atrophy? Second, Terri's cerebral cortex has not been replaced by fluid. That is inaccurate. The cortex is thinned and the sulci a... [Read More]

» THE TRIUMPH OF INTENTIONAL IGNORANCE from JunkYardBlog
The blogosphere, once known for its niche punditry and its thousands of angles on every story, is now home to a new innovation: The triumph of intentional ignorance. Look around. Over here, you'll see go-to blogger Glenn Reynolds--a law professor--utte... [Read More]

» Analyze This from This Vehicle Makes Wide Right Turns
"MY Vast Right Wing Conspiracy" points to CodeBlueBlog's analysis of Terri Schiavo's CT scan from 1996. CodeBlue explains how the Second District court's analysis of the scan is inaccurate, and offers his own take. [Read More]

» Shiavo roundup from The Bellman

Two federal courts have now refused to order that Terri Shiavo's feeding tube be reinserted. That leaves only the U.S. Supreme Court, but they have twice previously refused to intervene in the case. Before we put this whole sordid business behind us, [Read More]

» Dr. Boyle: No evidence Terri Schiavo's Mental Abilities Eradicated from OpinionBug.com
Dr. Boyle at CodeBlueBlog says there is "NO PRIMA FACIE EVIDENCE THAT TERRI SCHIAVO'S MENTAL ABILITIES OR/OR CAPABILITIES ARE COMPLETELY ERADICATED": CodeBlueBlog—I HAVE SEEN MANY WALKING, TALKING, FAIRLY COHERENT PEOPLE WITH WORSE CEREBRAL... [Read More]

» Terri Schiavo Update IX from Pajama Hadin
11th Circuit Court Appeal Denied for Terri PINELLAS PARK, Fla. -— After losing two consecutive appeals in federal court, Terri Schiavo's parents vowed today to take their fight to the U.S. Supreme Court as their severely brain-damaged daughter began... [Read More]

» Terry Schiavo from Argghhh! The Home Of Two Of Jonah's Military Guys..
AS WE PASS 100 HOURS OF STARVATION AND DEHYDRATION ... [Andy McCarthy] it is worth remembering that the excruciating slowness of the execution here, the incremental-ness of death, is designed by its champions to inure us to it. After the... [Read More]

» Dr. Ditto Requested to Testify in Terry Schiavo Case from Janus Online
I just received the following letter. Apparently Ms. Jackson wasn’t reading very closely, or else she would have realized that I am neither a doctor nor do I support Congress’s unprecedented action in this case. The posting Ms. Jackson refe... [Read More]

» Schiavo Quick Hits from The American Mind
Time ticks away, and Terri moves closer to her Creator. I don't have the emotional stamina to say a lot... [Read More]

» Terri's Brain from hampsonbaby.blog-city.com
Check out this entry from CodeBlueBlog, an award winning medical blog.� This entry analyzes what appears to be a CT scan performed on Terri Schiavo in 1996.� I sort of have my doubts as to whether or not this is actually HER CT, but if it is, the i [Read More]

» More Terri Facts from The Greatest Pursuits

Over the last couple of days I’ve collected quite a number of facts about Terri’s case. Here is what I’ve found (in no particular order). Myths vs. Facts It’s clear that many people are unclear Terri Schiavo’s situation... [Read More]

» Terri's Brain from hampsonbaby.blog-city.com
Check out this entry from CodeBlueBlog, an award winning medical blog.� This entry analyzes what appears to be a CT scan performed on Terri Schiavo in 1996.� I sort of have my doubts as to whether or not this is actually HER CT, but if it is, the i [Read More]

» Even More on Terri Schiavo (Jerry K) from The Queen of All Evil
Adam, from the comments, provided another interesting link to Captain Normal's debunking of myths with the Schiavo case. While reviewing the Captain's page I saw ... [Read More]

» CodeBlueBlog has some questions regarding Terri Schiavo's CT Scan from Jeff Blogworthy.com
See the image from a CT scan of Terri Schiavo's brain in 1996 with accompanying commentary.I HAVE SEEN MANY WALKING, TALKING, FAIRLY COHERENT PEOPLE WITH WORSE CEREBRAL/CORTICAL ATROPHY. THEREFORE, THIS IS IN NO WAY PRIMA FACIE EVIDENCE THAT TERRI SCHIAVO [Read More]

» Schiavo's Brain from Cognitive Dissonance
Ive just come across a medical blog with a post on Terri Schiavo's much touted brain scan which purportedly showed the brain was filled with spinal fluid. This doctor's comments and analysis raise some interesting questions.Code Blue BlogThe most alarming [Read More]

» Pro-Life on the Left from Sierra Faith
Next, Liberals For Terri discuss the award-winning medical CodeBlueBlog question: IS THIS REALLY TERRI'S CT? Blogs for Terri has been doing a great job in making the fight for Terri's life non-partisan. [Read More]

» The CT Scan - Proof of PVS? A $100,000 Challenge from BlogsforTerri
Terri Schiavo's CT could be the brain of an eighty or ninety year old person who is not in a vegetative state. THOSE are the CT scans we should be showing next to Schiavo's, because in THAT case you would see similar atrophy and a brain much closer to ... [Read More]

» More Important Issues Regarding Terri Schiavo Case from Anchor Rising
This posting builds on five previous postings on Terri Schiavo (I, II, III, IV, V). I would encourage you to read Nat Henoff's editorial in the Village Voice on Terri Schiavo: For all the world to see, a 41-year-old woman,... [Read More]

» Stacked deck from In Context
Here's the thing about the Code Blue Blogger challenge (other than that the point is now basically moot). To prove my point I am offering... [Read More]

» Stacked deck from In Context
Here's the thing about the Code Blue Blogger challenge (other than that the point is now basically moot). To prove my point I am offering... [Read More]

» Stacked deck from In Context
Here's the thing about the Code Blue Blogger challenge (other than that the point is now basically moot). To prove my point I am offering... [Read More]

» Stacked deck from In Context
Here's the thing about the Code Blue Blogger challenge (other than that the point is now basically moot). To prove my point I am offering... [Read More]

» Stacked deck from In Context
Here's the thing about the Code Blue Blogger challenge (other than that the point is now basically moot). To prove my point I am offering... [Read More]

» Stacked deck from In Context
Here's the thing about the Code Blue Blogger challenge (other than that the point is now basically moot). To prove my point I am offering... [Read More]

» Code Blue from Delftsman
D.r Boyle of Code Blue Blog has some interesting things to say about Terri Shiavo's last CT scan, done in 1996... Whats more, he is willing to put his money where his mouth is. Just remember some of his points... [Read More]

» Remember that CAT Scan? from The Original Musings
Is there anything that's being reported fairly in this case? Just go read it. The summary: The Court's position on the CAT Scan is wrong. But wait, it's gonna get worse. The summary: Terri did not suffer brain damage outside... [Read More]

» Human rights watch, cont. from Kesher Talk
Previous Terri Schiavo posts here and here. Here is a technical discussion of her CAT scan, by a radiologist with 15 years experience:... [Read More]

» StorageTek from Insure Blog
What does this ruling mean? If it stands up on appeal, it means StorageTek has a monopoly on service for all of its machines. No independent vendor will be able to compete with them for service contracts because no independent vendor... [Read More]

Comments

Craig H

Unless someone can find evidence that Ms. Schiavo ever had a shunt placed, this is not her head CT. Also, this is one cut -- where's the rest of the CT? Elementary radiologic interpretation: make sure the name on the film matches the name of the patient.

Suspicious, but certainly willing to be informed,

CodeBlueBlogMD

There is no name on the CT (I assume) because HIPPA regulations forbid it.

They only provided me with one cut; however, when you have the type of experience I DO (I've seen 10,000 brain CT's) you can pretty well infer the rest of the study. Granted there could be OTHER surprises on the scan; however, I can judge the severity of GLOBAL ISCHEMIA-caused atrophy based on this cut, and I'm willing to BET on it.

You are correct about that shunt -- that is really remarkable. Why would they shunt her unless she had obstructive hydrocephalus -- and how did she GET THAT?!

Craig H

Karen Quinlan's pathology was disproportionately subcortical -- bithalamic ischemia -- with relative cortical sparing. That's why the other cuts matter, and why the functional severity of the hypoxic injury can't be inferred from this picture.

No matter though. Tere's no indication from any of the medical or legal timelines available (online anyway) that Ms. Schiavo ever had a shunt.

CodeBlueBlogMD

They specifically say, in all documents and releases, that it is Terri Schiav's CORTEXZ that was affected, which is the focus of the injury one would expect given the mechanism of cardiac dysrythmmia leading to global cerebral ischemia.

Selective thalamic ischemia is quite unusual. I don't remember Quinlan's etiology but selective thalamic ischemia is usually a poisoning -- such as carbon monoxide, I believe -- something that has not been adduced as a mechanism for Schiavo.

In any event, I am not saying that I do not want to see the entire CT -- I do! This is all they are providing us with; and if THIS is what they based this case on, they have made a HUGE error.

CodeBlueBlogMD

One more thing...part of the perception of Schiavo's atrophy is THE SIZE OF THE VENTRICLES! To the interpreter of a CT scan, hugely dilated ventricles in the setting of diffuse atrophy suggests hydrocephalus ex vacuo: enlarged ventricles due to the NEGATIVE pressure effect of atrophied cortex. And this observation WORSENS the severity of the cortical atrophy in the perception of the interpreter.

Patricia

I'm in neuropsych and am not qualified to read CT's, but even I can tell there's a problem with their reading if this is her CT.

It's been reported that she spoke a few words and walked some with parallel bars when she was in rehab, but I don't know if that report is accurate.

What to do???

DrTony

I heard an interview on the radio today with a physician who has over 10 hours evaluating Terri. He stated that she is not unconscious. He indicated that when he commented on the scene outside her hospital room window, she turned to look out the window. She vocalizes in an attempt to communicate. The discussion on the radio also discussed affadavits from nurses who swore that Mike refused treatment with antibiotics for UTI's, refused to allow evals by rehab physicians and refused imaging studies such as MRI and PET scans.

The physician being interviewed also stated that his opinion, based on a review of the medical records, is that Mr. Shiavo deliberately moved Terri from nursing home to nursing home whenever the staff would get suspicious about his refusal of care. One nurse quoted Mr. Shiavo as saying, "Let the bitch die."

NotADoctor

Are you sure that's a shunt? In the reports filed she had some electronic stimulation gadget implanted in her brain, at the request of her husband, not too long after her "accident".

Claire

I have seen a couple of references to a shunt and questions to why it had been allowed to remain in place this long.

Still looking for *where* I saw them...

Also references to full sepsis after a time with no antibiotics for a UTI. At that point a court stepped in and enforced the law that forbids a guardian to withhold basic medical care. There was a reference to the sepsis causing further brain damage, but I've no idea if that is possible. Is it?

Claire

I have seen a couple of references to a shunt and questions to why it had been allowed to remain in place this long.

Still looking for *where* I saw them...

Also references to full sepsis after a time with no antibiotics for a UTI. At that point a court stepped in and enforced the law that forbids a guardian to withhold basic medical care. There was a reference to the sepsis causing further brain damage, but I've no idea if that is possible. Is it?

NotADoctor

Found this little tidbit in a google search:

27. Judge Greer has allowed violation of 744.3215(b) not requiring Michael to have follow up examinations of electrodes, which were implanted in Terri’s brain. These implants should have been removed years ago, as they are a source for both infection and hydrocephalus. Hydrocephalus may cause pressure that could suppress cognitive function and be responsible for much of Terri’s condition. If so, there could be a vast improvement in her condition if a shunt were placed. Hydrocephalus could also cause pressure that would flatten the brain and show fluid filled areas on a brain scan.

http://libertytothecaptives.net/judge_greer_violations_statutes.html

I am not a physician, that's why I am asking all of you. Is that really a shunt on the CT or one of those implanted electrodes, and could the electrodes account for the amount of hydrocephalus found? Why are people asking for a shunt, if a shunt is already there? Wouldn't placement of such show up in the medical record or be noticed on subsequent physician examinations, and therefore noted?

Just asking.

caltechgirl

I too want to see the rest of the scan if it is indeed Terri's. Thanks for posting what I've been trying to point out, but have far less credibility to say (I've taught 1st year med students what to look for in CTs and done research with MRIs, but I don't do this for a living, being a lowly PhD student). I've seen a worse-looking scan of a conscious, talking person, but again, the differences were in other slices.... I'll look forward to whatever else you dig up.

CodeBlueBlogMD

That's a shunt tip, for sure.

First, if you implant an "electrode" the purpose is for the electrode to "stimulate" neural tissue for some effect. There is no neural tissue floating in the CSF inside that venticle. Implantable electrodes would need be superficial.

That is the tip of a venticulatr shunt which we are only seeing on one scan slice (because that's all we have). It was placed there to relieve increased intraventicular pressure which can have 2 causes: overproduction of CSF or obstruction to CSF outflow (= "communicating" and "noncommunicating" hydrocephalus).

Here is the important part: In a patient of her age, given her circumstances, this would almost surely be "noncommunicating" hydrocephalus, which is almost always caused, in this situation, by a "clot" at the level of the ventricular drainage (Foramen of Magendie; which is EXTRAAXIAL, meaning that the clot had its genesis OUTSIDE OF THE NEUROAXIS...to a specialist this means she had BLOOD IN HER CSF.

How do you get that?

From getting smashed on the head (as in an assault).

So how would she have got smashed on the head?

Why don't we know this?

Why can't I find refenerence to this shunt in her case?

Stop the presses, someone.

NotADoctor

Thank you very much for your answer. Is there a reason why hydrocephalus would be due more so to old injury than to the long-term effects of the electrode placement?

Just trying to get all my facts in a row....

CodeBlueBlogMD

There IS NO electrode.

This is a plastic tube (= a shunt) placed there to RELIEVE an obstruction.

THAT obstruction is the element in discussion: how did she get it?

Most comony THAT obstruction would be secondary to bleeding OUTSIDE of the brain tissue (= subarachnoid or subdural hemorrhage). How does one GET this get of hemorrhage?

FROM TRAUMA. LIKE A SMASH ON THE HEAD.

NotADoctor

I'm sorry, I didn't make myself clear. I know what a shunt is, I'm speaking of the electrodes that were implanted in her brain in 1992, which have never been removed, and to which some would explain the resulting hydrocephalus on the CT in 1996.

**Ms. Schiavo could be evaluted with a PET scan in her current condition. However, an MRI cannot be done without first removing experimental electrodes which were implanted within her brain in 1992. The doctor who implanted them instructed Mr. Schiavo to have them removed, but that has not been done.[13]

(http://www.nationalreview.com/script/printpage.asp?ref=/comment/johansen200503160848.asp)**

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terri_Schiavo



Mark

These comments are intriguing. I've linked to them on my blog.

CodeBlueBlogMD

I don't see any signs of electrodes on this slice of the CT.

Also, I know of no electrodes that anyone would leave in any brain for any purpose, and in 20 years of seeing more than 10,000 CT's of the brain, I have never observed such a phenomenon.

In addition, it is hard to believe that anyone inserted electrodes, in 1992, that had paramagnetic properties that would preclude an MRI of the brain currently. I doubt that. Most of those devices are titanium or stainless steel, which are unaffected by MRI. Besides, with MRI, in that type of situation, the only reason not to do an MRI is because you are looking for information in the region of the artifact, where there would be distortion of the image.

If the items are not paramagnetic (like iron), there would be no danger and no contraindication to an MRI. Sounds bogus to me.

Finally, yes, if someone penetrated the dural linings of her brain with electrodes, that procedure could possibly (but not likely) have created a hemorrhage that resulted in hydrocephalus. But I have a long way to go before I believe that.

NotADoctor

According to Michael Schiavo's November 19, 1993 deposition, case No. 90-2908-GD, the electrodes implanted were platinum.

NotADoctor

The experimental procedure was performed by Dr. Yoshio Hosobuchi of the University of California at San Francisco.

NotADoctor

Hosobuchi Y, Yingling C.
The treatment of prolonged coma with neurostimulation.
Adv Neurol. 1993;63:247-51. No abstract available.
PMID: 8279309 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]

Ed Jordan

CodeBlue,

If you want to contact someone close to the Schindlers to share your discoveries, one person to contact is Rev. Robert Johansen of the Thrown Back blog. Fr. Johansen is a friend of the Schindler family, and he has been gathering the names of physicians who think Terri can recover. I think he would be interested in hearing from you.

http://www.thrownback.blogspot.com/

[email protected]

Michael Ditto

Have you ever treated a heart attack patient? To suggest that the only way someone could get blood in the CSF is being "smashed on the head (as in an assault)" is curious. Would you care to back that up with some data? Are you saying that there is no such thing as heparin-induced thrombocytopenia?

Michael, he's basing his assesment on "20 years of seeing more than 10,000 CT's of the brain". I think he's perfectly qualified to form an opinion without having to quantify it with data.

Anyway, this whole thread is misleading. You can't judge a patients neurological health TODAY based on a CT from 1996.

The fact that there is no CT from 2005 is what is really disturbing. Also the fact that there has been no INDEPENDENT review of Ms. Schiavo's current neurological condition.

The fact that there was hydrocephalus in 1996 just proves the neglect on the part of the Guardian of Ms. Schiavo. That alone should be enough to require a review of her treatment and an independent investigation into factual nature of her disability.

Right now all we have are arguments from two parties that are equally biased. Why won't Michael Schiavo let DCF perform their own investigation as they have petitioned the court to do?

Curious JD

Would you allow someone you did not know whose motives are directly adverse to what you believe your spouse wanted just because they petitioned the court?

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

2004 WINNER: BEST CLINICAL SCIENCES MEDICAL WEBLOG

What People Are Saying

  • "Dr. Boyle is a man of strong views and good will...read the weblog."
    Brad DeLong-- Semi-Daily Journal
  • "My New Favorite Internet Obsession"
    cripes, suzette
  • "Marvelous Medical Blog"
    Ambivalog
  • "Entertaining and lluminating"
    Counterpunch Magazine
  • "Enjoyable Weblog"
    Alexander Cockburn
  • "I have found a new medical blog, and a blogging hero."
    Liz Ditz-- I Speak of Dreams
  • "Your Blog Rocks!"
    Allyson Dyar-- DyarStraights.Com
  • "A remarkable blog."
    Eric Scheie – Cultural Values
  • "Good thoughts"
    E. Moritz-- Life Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness